God who knows our darkest moments (website only)

A hymn for Aberfan

On 21 October 1966, a coal waste tip overlooking the village of Aberfan, destabilised by rain water, slid and crashed down into Pantglas Junior School, destroying most of the school as well as a farm and twenty houses. The avalanche killed 144 people including 116 children. It’s the worst disaster involving children in modern British history.

The Revd Gareth Hill’s hymn, “God who knows our darkest moments”, was written for personal reasons. Gareth’s father-in-law, the Revd Irving Penberthy, now a supernumerary minister in Okehampton, Devon, is the only surviving church leader from those who were ministering in Aberfan at the time of the tragedy. See below for more information.

Aberfan Cemetery - two rows of white arches mark the graves of children killed in the 1966 colliery tip disaster © Stephen McKay (Licensed under Creative Commons)

God who knows our darkest moments
meets us in our brokenness:
walks beside us as a whisper,
holds our pain in his caress.
God, who leads through shadowed valleys,
where death’s bleakness dims our sight,
speaks a peace beyond our knowing,
floods our anguish with his light.

Far beyond our grief’s horizon,
as Creation holds its breath:
Love Divine, revealed in Jesus,
tears apart the chains of death.
Servant son and humble healer,
by your cross and life laid down
you have carried all our suff’ring
and you wear the victor’s crown.

Lift us up, now, risen Saviour
to the place where mercy plays,
where our broken hopes and heartache
find their healing in your gaze.
This is love, that God has saved us!
This is love, that Christ has died!
We rejoice that love has conquered
and has drawn us to your side.

Words: © Gareth Hill Publishing/Song Solutions CopyCare, 14 Horsted Square, Uckfield, TN22 1QG www.songsolutions.org

Metre: 87.87.D

Suggested tune: Dim ond Iesu (StF 713) – a Welsh tune for a Welsh community, as Gareth says.

Ideas for use

The tramway that took waste from Aberfan colliery to the spoil heaps high above the village © John Thorn – taken in 1964, two years before the heaps collapsed (Licensed under Creative Commons)

With the line “God, who leads through shadowed valleys” (v.1), Gareth Hill evokes both the former mining valleys of South Wales, scene of the 1966 disaster, and the unfailing presence of God as described in Psalm 23. Indeed, the opening lines, spoken quietly, have something about them of Ben E. King’s intimately yearning lyric, “Stand by me”.

Gareth also points out that there is a double allusion in the final verse, which images heaven both as healing place and playground – “the place where mercy plays”, we hope both for the children of Aberfan and for us all.

For although this hymn arose from the memories of a specific event, it stretches beyond the singular to the general and eternal: “Love Divine, revealed in Jesus, tears apart the chains of death.” (v.2) This is a text that acknowledges personal and community grief which, in its diverse forms, affects us all at different times in our lives:

Lift us up, now, risen Saviour
to the place where mercy plays,
where our broken hopes and heartache
find their healing in your gaze.

See also David Lee’s paraphrase of Psalm 130, Out of the depths I cry to you, O Lord, set to the tune Gresford – “the miners’ hymn”, which was written to commemorate the 1934 Gresford mining disaster.

More information

Licensed under Creative Commons

Pupils at Pantglas Junior School were just beginning their first lessons of the day when the rushing landslide of mud and debris from the nearby spoil heap – half a million tonnes of waste – flooded into their classrooms.

Some children were able to escape, but 116 were killed. Another 28 adults also died. The local community was devastated by the tragedy.

The Revd Irving Penberthy had moved to Aberfan in 1963 to minister at the English-speaking Zion Methodist Church. Gareth writes:

“The Methodist Sunday School was devastated and Irving spent months working with the community to support the families: recording an LP, funding a new youth centre alongside the chapel and administering a fund of donations from Methodist people all over the world. Part of his immediate work included accompanying parents at an emergency morgue as they identified their children.”

Irving Penberthy was invited to speak at the 50th anniversary memorial service in 2016 and Gareth’s hymn was written for that service.

Irving recalls the disaster and his ministry in Aberfan in a sequence of four Youtube videos. Further memories can be read on the BBC’s On This Day page.

Categories: 87.87.D. (Iambic), Conflict, Suffering and Doubt, Dim ond Iesu, Hill, Gareth, Hymns only online (submit to stfplus@methodistchurch.org.uk), Jesus Risen and Ascended.

3 Responses to God who knows our darkest moments (website only)

  1. keith robinson says:

    I remember watching the TV in a common room at Southlands College, Wimbledon on that night in October 1966 and seeing it on Songs of Praise brought it all back. So emotional.

    I am using the words of the hymn in a sermon on Sunday 30th October in the Stockton Methodist Church circuit. The sermon is about doubt and faith and based on Habakkuk, especially chapter 3 verses 17-19.

  2. Alex Kent says:

    Had to trace details of hymn after hearing it sung on Songs of Praise 23rd October 2016 for Aberfan Tribute.
    Beautiful and touching words resonated as we lost our Son 22 years ago and could enter all the families that lost loved ones in Aberfan.
    Thank You.

  3. John Davies says:

    I heard this sung for the very first time tonight on Songs of Praise and was profoundly moved by the words. It helps immensely that they are sung to one of my favourite tunes – Blaenwern’, and I sang along aloud as if I had known it all my life.

    As a Christian I felt them to be marvelous words, strong, comforting and reassuring in the worst of life’s situations. This is truly getting to the depths of reality, the God who is there in the darkest moments. Thank you for them.

    I was thirteen when the Aberfan tragedy happened – it was only in later life that the enormity of it all really dawned on me. A wicked waste. Now it makes me grateful for the life God has given me.

    Nos da, cariads. Sleep well.

Leave a comment below

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>